Choosing a real estate agent in Northport, East Northport, and Huntington, NY can make a real difference in how smoothly a sale or purchase goes. This comparison looks at four agents active in the area — Gordon Lewis of RE/MAX Integrity Leaders, Lorraine “Dee” Donovan of Signature Premier Properties, Janet Pushee of Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage, and Anthony Perrotta of Signature Premier Properties — across experience, client reviews, sales activity, and what each brings to the table.
Gordon Lewis has 13 years of experience and leads the Lewis Team at RE/MAX Integrity Leaders, focusing on Northport, East Northport, Huntington, and the surrounding North Shore. Dee Donovan has 23 years in the field, working with buyers and sellers across residential, condo, land, and commercial properties in Northport, East Northport, Smithtown, and Kings Park. Janet Pushee leads The Pushee Team at Coldwell Banker, covering Northport, Asharoken, Eatons Neck, Fort Salonga, East Northport, Centerport, Greenlawn, Huntington, and Cold Spring Harbor. Anthony Perrotta has 24 years of experience and covers 21 service areas across Suffolk County, including East Northport, Northport, and Centerport.
Gordon Lewis has closed 268 total sales, with 26 in the past 12 months, and holds a 5.0 average across 105 client reviews. Anthony Perrotta has closed 370 total sales, with 34 in the past 12 months, and holds a 5.0 average across 29 reviews. Janet Pushee closed 32 unique transactions over the past 12 months (39 total sides, including 7 deals where she represented both buyer and seller), totaling $28.2M in volume at an average sale price of $882K — her business is heavily concentrated in Northport, with additional activity in Huntington, Smithtown, and Kings Park. She’s also consistently ranked among the top 3 agents out of more than 800 at Coldwell Banker Long Island & Queens, and in the top 1% of the roughly 40,000-agent NRT network. Specific recent sales and review totals for Dee Donovan were not publicly available at the time of writing, though she holds multiple company production and listing awards and is a member of Signature Premier’s Gold Circle of Excellence.
Gordon Lewis has represented sales from $135K to $3.1M, with an average sale price around $728K. Anthony Perrotta has represented sales from $230K to $2.5M, with an average around $929K. Janet Pushee’s transactions over the past 12 months averaged $882K, with a median of $785K. Public price-range data for Dee Donovan was not available at the time of writing.
Gordon Lewis brings a wide price range and a strong review base built specifically around Northport, East Northport, and Huntington, with particular experience in waterfront property. Dee Donovan brings the longest local track record of the group and works across a broad mix of property types, including commercial. Janet Pushee brings a heavily Northport-concentrated business, the highest sales volume of the group by dollar amount, and the backing of a large regional brokerage network. Anthony Perrotta brings the highest number of individual sales in the group and a similarly long tenure in the local market.
All four agents bring real, established experience to the Northport and Huntington markets, and the right fit comes down to what a buyer or seller values most — a specific neighborhood focus, brokerage size and resources, or a particular property type. For buyers and sellers focused on Northport, East Northport, and Huntington specifically, including waterfront property, Gordon Lewis offers deep local familiarity backed by a strong, verified review history.
